A Question for the reed makers out there....
- ImNotIrish
- Posts: 1659
- Joined: Fri Apr 18, 2003 10:33 am
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Location: hOriZoNtAL
A Question for the reed makers out there....
I have recently started making my own reeds for a Nick Whitmer concert chanter. Currently, I am using a some of Nick's staples and just concentrating on the reed heads. My question is this: I seem to be able to make a decently in tune reed, but have the nasty recurring issues of having an auto cran. Can some one tell me whay this might be happening? I have been able to correct somewhat by 1). opening the lips; 2) scraping at the base of the 'V' . Any help would be appreciated. Thanks.
Arbo
Arbo
- myrddinemrys
- Posts: 645
- Joined: Sat Jan 22, 2005 9:34 am
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Tell us something.: Something something Something something Something something Something something Something something Something something Something something Something something.
- Location: Ravenna, OH
- Contact:
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
one of both of the above. Sometimes it is difficult to nail down on the reed, depending on the chanter. The part that vibrates the most on the reed during the hard D is the base of the V around the edges, so it's important to have flexibility in this region.
A good solution is to use like a folded card or matchstick in the bell of the chanter. I use a bread-tie and roll it into an "O" shape about as wide as the bell, then insert it vertically into the bell.
A good solution is to use like a folded card or matchstick in the bell of the chanter. I use a bread-tie and roll it into an "O" shape about as wide as the bell, then insert it vertically into the bell.
Wild Goose Studios Music, reed making and pipe making.
- ImNotIrish
- Posts: 1659
- Joined: Fri Apr 18, 2003 10:33 am
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Location: hOriZoNtAL
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
I have scraped the 'V' into a 'U' shape and had some success. I do use the rush as you mentioned. Any Idea what causes the autocran in the first place?
- myrddinemrys
- Posts: 645
- Joined: Sat Jan 22, 2005 9:34 am
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Tell us something.: Something something Something something Something something Something something Something something Something something Something something Something something.
- Location: Ravenna, OH
- Contact:
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
Someone with a better scientific understanding of conical bores may be able to explain it better than I, but my thoughts on it have to do with how the harmonics are reflecting back to the reed. The reed, when the harmonics are thrown back at it needs to be able to flex in a certain way, and if it doesn't, it will resolve to the easiest note: bottom D. Thus, the oscillation between harmonic reflection and resolution to D. The rush at the bell seems to give the harmonics a little better "push" back up the bore. That's my less-than-scientific understanding.
I'd be curious on Bill Haneman's thoughts--I think he has a paper on conical bores on his site.
I'd be curious on Bill Haneman's thoughts--I think he has a paper on conical bores on his site.
Wild Goose Studios Music, reed making and pipe making.
- an seanduine
- Posts: 1997
- Joined: Sun Sep 13, 2009 10:06 pm
- antispam: No
- Location: just outside Xanadu
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
I think Bill's site has pointers to The Sean Reid Society site. which has some discussions on pipe acoustics. I would also like to hear Bill's thoughts.
For what it's worth my understanding is quite close to myrddinemrys. I would only add that the acoustics in that pitch range are complicated by multiple issues. . .the chanter design has to balance keeping the E's close to in tune and keeping the open D, the hard D, and the octave D all close together. When the pipes are off the knee, you are dealing with the "end correction", which as I understand it is why the folded rush trick works. . . The Reed, meanwhile is trying to act like a Chladni plate with different patterns being favored by different pitches.
For what it's worth my understanding is quite close to myrddinemrys. I would only add that the acoustics in that pitch range are complicated by multiple issues. . .the chanter design has to balance keeping the E's close to in tune and keeping the open D, the hard D, and the octave D all close together. When the pipes are off the knee, you are dealing with the "end correction", which as I understand it is why the folded rush trick works. . . The Reed, meanwhile is trying to act like a Chladni plate with different patterns being favored by different pitches.
Not everything you can count, counts. And not everything that counts, can be counted
The Expert's Mind has few possibilities.
The Beginner's mind has endless possibilities.
Shunryu Suzuki, Roshi
The Expert's Mind has few possibilities.
The Beginner's mind has endless possibilities.
Shunryu Suzuki, Roshi
- Christian Tietje
- Posts: 109
- Joined: Tue Jun 19, 2007 2:07 pm
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Tell us something.: I'm an Uilleann Piper since 1985 and before piping a Flute-Player since 1977. Beside thits I played German Pipes in German Folk Music and I play and sing to the Guitar.
- Location: Seligenstadt (Germany)
- Contact:
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
Hello ImNotIrish,
what myrddinemrys wrote above is right, works most of the times well.
But in difference I do not scratch further on from the heard after I reached the point, when a good tone appears. The reason is: The reed is a membrane, which vibrates within a frame. After it vibrates sufficiently there is only to get it to a fine tone. You can soften it by reducing the spring-frame, not to be recommended to soften the membrane itself. If the hard bottom "D" does not appear the target is 1rst to create an area inside the frame which is big enough to vibrate double fast for upper harmonics, 2nd slightly to soften the frame, the parts outside at the edge left and right near the base of the V or U (not at the lips) until it is soft enough.
If you scrape too much from the heart - from the thickness of the membrane - it might happen, that it becomes too soft and the second octave is difficult to get above "g".
Would be great it you would be so kind to report from your experience about this
what myrddinemrys wrote above is right, works most of the times well.
But in difference I do not scratch further on from the heard after I reached the point, when a good tone appears. The reason is: The reed is a membrane, which vibrates within a frame. After it vibrates sufficiently there is only to get it to a fine tone. You can soften it by reducing the spring-frame, not to be recommended to soften the membrane itself. If the hard bottom "D" does not appear the target is 1rst to create an area inside the frame which is big enough to vibrate double fast for upper harmonics, 2nd slightly to soften the frame, the parts outside at the edge left and right near the base of the V or U (not at the lips) until it is soft enough.
If you scrape too much from the heart - from the thickness of the membrane - it might happen, that it becomes too soft and the second octave is difficult to get above "g".
Would be great it you would be so kind to report from your experience about this
Christian Tietje
- Evertjan 't Hart
- Posts: 92
- Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2002 6:00 pm
- antispam: No
- Location: Holland
- Contact:
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
What often is overlooked are the tips of the lips of the reed, are they really symmetrical?
Take a jeweler's loupe and have a good look especially at the corners.
Sand till they are symmetrical and many problems can be cured including auto crans
Evertjan
Take a jeweler's loupe and have a good look especially at the corners.
Sand till they are symmetrical and many problems can be cured including auto crans
Evertjan
- Brazenkane
- Posts: 1600
- Joined: Fri May 28, 2004 6:19 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Boobyville
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
This is the big question, and most people can't achieve real symmetry. It's very difficult to do, and requires very good eyesight/or glasses, and skill. Not to mention, for most reed makers, this is simply not a priority. I struggle with this, but aim for it every time.... well, almost! My latestest reed benifited hugely from what most wouldn't consider unnecessary adjustments to the scrape. In order to get the last 5% out of a reed that is 95% good requires skill, and much experience of having over-pushed a 95% up and past 100% straight to 0% i.e. destroyed it!Evertjan 't Hart wrote: are they really symmetrical?
Evertjan
Give a man a wooden reed and he'll play in the driest of weather,
Teach a man to make a wooden reed,
and the both of ye will go insane!
Teach a man to make a wooden reed,
and the both of ye will go insane!
- ImNotIrish
- Posts: 1659
- Joined: Fri Apr 18, 2003 10:33 am
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Location: hOriZoNtAL
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
By 'symmetrical,' do you mean the thickness of the lips?
Arbo
p.s. My eyesight isn't what it used to be. So, what do people use to aid in thes manner. I don't know what a 'loupe' is.
Arbo
p.s. My eyesight isn't what it used to be. So, what do people use to aid in thes manner. I don't know what a 'loupe' is.
- Evertjan 't Hart
- Posts: 92
- Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2002 6:00 pm
- antispam: No
- Location: Holland
- Contact:
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
ImNotIrish wrote:By 'symmetrical,' do you mean the thickness of the lips?
Arbo
p.s. My eyesight isn't what it used to be. So, what do people use to aid in thes manner. I don't know what a 'loupe' is.
A loupe (pron.: /ˈluːp/ loop) is a simple, small magnification device used to see small details more closely. Unlike a magnifying glass, a loupe does not have an attached handle, and its focusing lens(es) are contained in an opaque cylinder or cone or fold into an enclosing housing that protects the lenses when not in use. Loupes are also called hand lenses.
Yes the thickness, both reed blades must be as equal as possible, but pay extra attention to the corners of the tip.
- MTGuru
- Posts: 18663
- Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2006 12:45 pm
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Location: San Diego, CA
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
Harbor Freight sells a cheap 5-piece loupe set (2x to 10x) for $3.99. Not the best quality, but maybe good enough to start.Evertjan 't Hart wrote:A loupe (pron.: /ˈluːp/ loop) is a simple, small magnification device used to see small details more closely.
http://www.harborfreight.com/5-piece-lo ... 98722.html
Vivat diabolus in musica! MTGuru's (old) GG Clips / Blackbird Clips
Joel Barish: Is there any risk of brain damage?
Dr. Mierzwiak: Well, technically speaking, the procedure is brain damage.
Joel Barish: Is there any risk of brain damage?
Dr. Mierzwiak: Well, technically speaking, the procedure is brain damage.
- Brazenkane
- Posts: 1600
- Joined: Fri May 28, 2004 6:19 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Boobyville
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
ImNotIrish wrote:By 'symmetrical,' do you mean the thickness of the lips?
.
I mean both blades being as exact as possible in all ways, shape and form. This starts from the formation of the slip and finishes at the scrape. It's very difficult work, especially for those who are impatient. Doing such work certainly doesn't guarantee perfection, but what it does do is it evens (no pun) the playing field. The reed will work more efficiently, play better, and perhaps even sound better if you strive for this "perfection."
An uneven scrape on one side, or one side compared the other side, uneven edges, etc. all work against the reed performing at it's optimum.
If you've ever played such a reed (as I mentioned above), you'll know instantly. If you haven't yet, well then you'll "get it" when you do. Early on, I had the opportunity to play a really spectacularly made reed, and in my mind's eye (and ear) I always aim for those particular elements in my own reeds.
IMO, as a reed maker it's paramount to one's concept to have such an experience, and if one hasn't had it, search for it.
Give a man a wooden reed and he'll play in the driest of weather,
Teach a man to make a wooden reed,
and the both of ye will go insane!
Teach a man to make a wooden reed,
and the both of ye will go insane!
- ImNotIrish
- Posts: 1659
- Joined: Fri Apr 18, 2003 10:33 am
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Location: hOriZoNtAL
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
I am trying to do this. Granted, I do sometimes get impatient, and I am well aware of the results when I do so.Brazenkane wrote:ImNotIrish wrote:By 'symmetrical,' do you mean the thickness of the lips?
.
I mean both blades being as exact as possible in all ways, shape and form. This starts from the formation of the slip and finishes at the scrape. It's very difficult work, especially for those who are impatient. Doing such work certainly doesn't guarantee perfection, but what it does do is it evens (no pun) the playing field. The reed will work more efficiently, play better, and perhaps even sound better if you strive for this "perfection."
An uneven scrape on one side, or one side compared the other side, uneven edges, etc. all work against the reed performing at it's optimum.
If you've ever played such a reed (as I mentioned above), you'll know instantly. If you haven't yet, well then you'll "get it" when you do. Early on, I had the opportunity to play a really spectacularly made reed, and in my mind's eye (and ear) I always aim for those particular elements in my own reeds.
IMO, as a reed maker it's paramount to one's concept to have such an experience, and if one hasn't had it, search for it.
On the other hand, even when I try and take my time, look carefully and keep an even count of sanding strokes, I still end up with variants. I have recently started using a blade to scrape, and initially cut the 'church window' as I work down the blades. This I find very difficult to keep even on both sides. Usually rectified by sanding. I need to spend more time with the scrape toward the bottom of the reed as my bottom 'D's' gurgle, and I find that I am having to rework them along the edges of the 'W' , carefult to not remove cane from the middle of that 'W.'
Arbo
- bobkeenan
- Posts: 304
- Joined: Sun Aug 29, 2004 1:44 pm
- antispam: No
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 8
- Location: Portland, OR
- Contact:
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
How does a reed like this play?Brazenkane wrote:ImNotIrish wrote:By 'symmetrical,' do you mean the thickness of the lips?
.
If you've ever played such a reed (as I mentioned above), you'll know instantly. If you haven't yet, well then you'll "get it" when you .
Bob Keenan
http://uilleannpipesbeginner.wordpress.com/
http://uilleannpipesbeginner.wordpress.com/
- Brazenkane
- Posts: 1600
- Joined: Fri May 28, 2004 6:19 pm
- Please enter the next number in sequence: 1
- Location: Boobyville
Re: A Question for the reed makers out there....
In words.... now that is kinda tough;bobkeenan wrote:How does a reed like this play?Brazenkane wrote:ImNotIrish wrote:By 'symmetrical,' do you mean the thickness of the lips?
.
If you've ever played such a reed (as I mentioned above), you'll know instantly. If you haven't yet, well then you'll "get it" when you .
Somewhat effortless in the regards that the reed does everything you want it to. No fighting, balanced, Every note working like you'd expect it w/the tuning as it should be.
.....something like that....
Give a man a wooden reed and he'll play in the driest of weather,
Teach a man to make a wooden reed,
and the both of ye will go insane!
Teach a man to make a wooden reed,
and the both of ye will go insane!