Chiff and Fipple Forums

OK, someone had to bring it up....It might as well be me.

So what do you think - Is Titanic good or bad for piping in general?

One other thought (something that's always bothered me) is how can Gaelic Storm claims to be the band from Titanic, but they have no piper in their group. The steerage scene is clearly all about the piper, isn't it? Maybe just my bias, but I know I was disappointed when I went to hear Gaelic Storm and found out there was no piper in the group.

OK, someone had to bring it up..

Why?

Waterford piper Brian Walsh used to be in the band and, if I remember correctly, was it's founder and driving force. After the movie came out they split up. I think it's good for piping in a very general sort of way in that it informs the general public that they exist. As we all know the VAST majority of humans have no idea what uilleann pipes are. It's our job to help get the word out

Patrick

At a gig the other day I had my first-ever request for "the theme from Titanic". When I failed to deliver that one I was asked for "the theme from Braveheart".

Same as it ever was...

Mr.Gumby wrote:Why?

A couple reasons:
It was a cultural phenomenon in 1997, and is, I believe, Sony Music's biggest selling album.
In the early 2000's many claimed that the movie was, at least partly, the reason for starting to play the pipes (Although I have to guess if that was the reason for starting, they probably are not still playing.)

So another wave of pipers coming, do you think? LOL

I think it wiz more of a phenomenom in 1912 As for the film ...moronic

Jarlath.I wrote: So another wave of pipers coming, do you think? LOL

LOL = "lots of luck"

Jarlath.I wrote:... and is, I believe, Sony Music's biggest selling album...

That might have more to do with Celine Dion than uilleann pipes.

I think that the movie was merely one of many elements that contributed to an increase in the popularity of pipes. Riverdance was another. Probably the most important was the Celtic Tiger which allowed the Irish government (and citizens) to invest more in the traditional arts and the cultural identity.

But none of them would have meant much if the strong foundations of piping had not already been laid by several generations of passionate pipers and pipemakers. This is what will sustain piping in the long term.

and, fwiw, GS does have a GHB/UP/whitle player. At least for their last 5 albums it's been Pete Purvis. Canadian, I think.

I think it's really Titanic 4D. The movie has become unstuck in the space-time continuum, and will continue to materialize in the present from time to time, like the Tardis.

Heres the best version of the film.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OuSdU8tbcHY

RORY

rorybbellows wrote:Heres the best version of the film.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OuSdU8tbcHY

No, no ... This is the best:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mV2ZKKtoefk

tommykleen wrote:At a gig the other day I had my first-ever request for "the theme from Titanic". When I failed to deliver that one I was asked for "the theme from Braveheart".

First ever? After all this time? Man. You must have been playing for abstemious folk in classier haunts than I.

rorybbellows wrote:Heres the best version of the film.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OuSdU8tbcHY

RORY

Patrick D'Arcy wrote:Waterford piper Brian Walsh used to be in the band and, if I remember correctly, was it's founder and driving force. After the movie came out they split up. I think it's good for piping in a very general sort of way in that it informs the general public that they exist. As we all know the VAST majority of humans have no idea what uilleann pipes are. It's our job to help get the word out

Patrick

WannabePiper wrote:and, fwiw, GS does have a GHB/UP/whitle player. At least for their last 5 albums it's been Pete Purvis. Canadian, I think.

Thanks for the info. Maybe I need to take another listen.

rorybbellows wrote:Heres the best version of the film.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OuSdU8tbcHY

RORY

This one even made my teenagers laugh!